Pyrex Butterprint Casserole value (November 2026)
Casserole · 1957–1968
Estimated sale price (used)
$22–$35
Middle of the market ≈ $27.45 · 320 for sale on eBay +4%
List at
$30.99
The going asking price, with room for offers.
Quick sale
$20.99
Priced to sell within days.
Based on current eBay asking prices (88 matching listings, Nov 12, 2026), discounted to estimate sold prices; updated weekly. Parts-only, untested and accessory listings are left out.
Price history
Listed on eBay now

$15.00
Vintage Pyrex 473 Butterprint Amish Turquoise 1 Qt Cinderella Casserole No Lid
(opens eBay in a new tab)
$23.99
Vintage Pyrex 472 1.5 Qt Turquoise Amish Butterprint Casserole Dish NO LID
(opens eBay in a new tab)
$29.99
Pyrex Glass Amish Butterprint Casserole Dish Blue Vintage #473 1qt
(opens eBay in a new tab)
$35.00
Vintage PYREX Amish Butterprint Turquoise 1.5 Pt Casserole Dish #472 With Lid
(opens eBay in a new tab)
$45.00
Vintage Pyrex 475-B Turquoise Blue Amish Butterprint 2 1/2 qt Casserole Bowl
(opens eBay in a new tab)
$99.99
Vintage PYREX Turquoise Amish BUTTERPRINT Casserole Set 471 472 Lids 1 & 1.5 pt
(opens eBay in a new tab)
About the Pyrex Butterprint Casserole
Butterprint (1957–1968) shows an Amish-style farm scene of a farmer and wife with a bushel of crops, roosters and corn, most often turquoise on white or the reverse. Casseroles include the Cinderella Bake Serve Store 471 (1 pt), 472 (1.5 pt) and 473 (1 qt), which came with clear lids. An original lid adds value, and fading from the dishwasher lowers it.
What affects the price
- An original matching lid adds real value.
- Colour strength and gloss: dishwasher damage and oven discolouration lower the price.
- Chips on the rim and handles, and utensil marks inside.
FAQ
How much is a Pyrex Butterprint Casserole worth?
As of November 2026, a used Pyrex Butterprint Casserole typically sells for about $22–$35, based on 88 current eBay listings. Asking prices are discounted about 12% to estimate what it actually sells for.
What should I list a Pyrex Butterprint Casserole for?
List at around $30.99 to sit mid-pack with room for offers, or around $20.99 to sell it quickly. Condition, what’s included and good photos move it up or down.
Are these sold prices?
No. eBay only shares sold prices with approved partners, so this guide uses current asking prices on eBay (items for sale right now), drops accessories, parts-only and outlier listings, and discounts the middle of the range to estimate the sale price. It is updated weekly.
How do I check the value of my own Pyrex Butterprint Casserole?
Use What’s It Worth? to search live eBay listings with your exact description and condition, or the FlipperTools extension to see sold prices on eBay’s own search pages.